Reviews

How to Give Upward Feedback (360°)

Guide to providing confidential feedback about your manager

2 min read

Upward feedback is a core part of Nami's 360-degree review process. It gives every team member a safe, confidential channel to share observations about their manager's leadership and support.

What Is Upward Feedback?

In a standard cycle, feedback flows downward (manager evaluates employee) and laterally (peer reviews). Upward feedback reverses the direction — you evaluate your manager, helping surface leadership strengths and blind spots.

Confidentiality Guarantees

  1. Responses are anonymized — your name is never attached to individual answers.
  2. Minimum rater threshold — results are withheld unless at least 3 people submit upward feedback for the same manager.

Info

If fewer than 3 direct reports complete upward feedback, the manager will not see any upward results for that cycle. Responses are stored securely but remain hidden.

How Nami Initiates It

When a cycle includes upward reviews, Nami sends you a Slack DM labeled Upward Feedback with your manager's name, the cycle name, deadline, and a "Let's go" button.

Step-by-Step Completion

  1. Tap "Let's go" in the Nami DM.
  2. Rate each competency on the 1-5 scale. Questions typically cover communication, support for growth, and decision-making.
  3. Provide written comments — be specific and focus on observable behaviors.
  4. Review and submit. Nami shows a summary before final submission.

Tip

Instead of "my manager is not supportive," describe a specific situation, the behavior you observed, and the impact it had.

How Managers See Results

Managers access upward feedback on the Reviews page and see:

  • Aggregated rating averages per competency (e.g., "Communication: 4.2 / 5")
  • Combined written comments without attribution
  • No individual response breakdown — there is no way to trace a comment to a specific person

Warning

HR and admins can see individual upward responses for audit purposes, but managers never have access to individual-level data.

Run this in Slack with Nami

Reviews, goals, surveys, and calibration — in the DM thread your team already reads. Free for teams of 10 or fewer.

More in Reviews